Alexander Report highly critical of education as it stands
A ‘play-based’ approach, both in and outside of the classroom and natural areas of the schoolgrounds, is beneficial for children that have these opportunities. I have seen this with my own eyes. We should also be starting formal education much later – aged 5 or 6!
Education made the front pages this week, with the 4-year report by Prof Robin Alexander, of Cambridge University on the state of education giving the Government a ‘poor’ in many areas…
The Government response, in a nutshell was: ‘we’ve had the Rose Review’ (sponsored by Government) which says we need to focus on ICT, Numeracy and Literacy … and science and the environment will happen by absorption! Note that the Government DOES NOT have to implement the Cambridge Review!
Some key points of Cambridge Report:
* ‘Primary education should amount to much more than basic literacy and
numeracy’ (Alexander)
My view: I agree! Children need a balanced curriculum including learning about the world about them – about, in and for the environment. Children can then use their environment – natural and built – using a source of inspiration for their writing and numeracy! This is also the view of the National Association for Environmental Education.
* Alexander praised the role of existing classroom “generalists” who are expected to teach all subjects. But it said there were concerns that some failed to provide the “expertise which a modern primary education requires”.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/6338706/Primary-review-specialist-teachers-for-infants.html
My view: Science is a key area in which schools that have a single or specialist teacher that undertakes this subject – as part of teachers ‘PPA’ time – children are better engaged in this area and the subject is often better resourced. I taught Science and Design and Technology and consider my specific focus on this subject and better collection of resources, than class teachers would easily be able to assemble, were an advantage.
* Children responded better to a “play-based” curriculum at a young age and insisted it would not hold them back in later life. Dame Gillian Pugh, the review’s chairman, said:
“If you introduce a child too formal a curriculum before they are ready for it then you are not taking into account where children are in terms of their learning and their capacity to develop. There is no research evidence that shows that early access to formal learning does children any good and quite a lot of good evidence to show that it actually can do some harm,” she said. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/6338700/Primary-review-start-formal-lessons-at-six.html
My view: Play-based approach using the resources both in and outside of the classroom/in the playground and natural areas of the schoolgrounds/local parks, has proved highly beneficial for children that have these opportunities. School grounds and Forest schools movements, and more specialist approaches such as Steiner and Montessori, are proof of children learning being effective here. My short time as a Nursery teacher and cover teaching at Foundation Stage verifies this.
Some useful links:
yes really the great thing is children can learn in a fun way. What they like very much, we all know that they can play games well. so we take the kids their own way to get education.
An interesting take with reference to your own experience. Very ‘Plowden’, if I might say, and I don’t mean that as an insult.
I am not a primary school specialist but managing change in the curriculum is an interest.
I haven’t read the Cambridge Primary Review yet and, for now, have just reflected on the political responses here http://pannage.blogspot.com/2009/10/interest-groups-and-school-curriculum.html
I suspect education is similar in Australia. My brother has taught in both and has good and bad things to say about each.In Oz there are difficulties for young teachers to get permanent positions.
As a parent it saddens me that there seem to be so many jaded teachers who stay and stay but there are lots of inspiring ones as well.
The sitting up straight and still has always bothered me as an observer. My eldest said to me when she was 5 ‘I nearly broke my back sitting up straight today and where did it get me? Nowhere.’ =no lolly.(As a teacher it must be a necessary tool, at least until we have tiny class sizes: and that’ll be when hell freezes over.)
I simply wanted to thank you very much once more. I do not know what I would have created without the type of hints revealed by you on this subject matter. Certainly was a very horrifying setting in my circumstances, however , being able to see a new specialised form you resolved it took me to weep with joy. Extremely happier for the information and thus hope that you really know what a powerful job you’re undertaking teaching people with the aid of your website. More than likely you have never come across any of us.
I cannot thank you adequately for the posts on your site. I know you set a lot of time and effort into all of them and really hope you know how deeply I enjoy it. I hope I’ll do a similar thing man or woman sooner or later.
very good post, i definitely love this website, carry on it
Thanks indeed. Yes and spread the word too if you like.
Regards!
Two thumbs up my friend, what an excellent post and worthy of my comment of praise.
It was a contentment getting to your site yesterday. I arrived here today hoping to get interesting things. And I was not frustrated. Your ideas for new strategies on this area were topical and a good help to me and my spouse. Thank you for having time to write out these things and then for sharing your thinking.
What would we do minus the marvellous tips you share on this site? Who else has the endurance to deal with critical topics with regard to common readers like me? I actually and my pals are very lucky to have your web site among the ones we usually visit. It is hoped you know how significantly we take pleasure in your working hard! Best wishes coming from us all.
There is apparently a bundle to identify about this. I consider you made various nice points in features also.
Hello. I want to give you a brief note to verbalize my thanks. I’ve been following your website for few weeks and have got a lot of good information and also enjoyed the way you have structured your website. I am going to run my own blog site however I believe it’s too general and I need to focus more on certain subjects.
A Little off topic perhaps, but anyways – which template are you using? I really love the CSS style.
I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this web site. I am hoping the same high-grade site post from you in the future also. Actually your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own blog going now. Really blogging is spreading its wings and growing quickly. Your write up is a great example.
Great story once again. I am looking forward for more updates!